Amazines Free Article Archive - Tuesday, July 23, 2019
Read about the most recent changes and happenings at
Log into your account or register as a new author. Start submitting your articles right now!
Search our database for articles.
Subscribe to receive articles emailed straight to your email account. You may choose multiple categories.
View our newest articles submitted by our authors.
View our most top rated articles rated by our visitors.
* Please note that this is NOT the ARTICLE manager
Add a new EZINE, or manage your EZINE submission.
Add fresh, free web content to your site such as newest articles, web tools, and quotes with a single piece of code!
Home What's New? Submit/Manage Articles Latest Posts Top Rated Article Search
Subscriptions Manage Ezines
 Article Archive
 Advertising (133298)
 Advice (160829)
 Affiliate Programs (34734)
 Art and Culture (73673)
 Automotive (145656)
 Blogs (75029)
 Boating (9841)
 Books (17123)
 Buddhism (4124)
 Business (1328339)
 Business News (426310)
 Business Opportunities (366258)
 Camping (10961)
 Career (72763)
 Christianity (15841)
 Collecting (11636)
 Communication (115054)
 Computers (241950)
 Construction (38993)
 Consumer (49679)
 Cooking (17061)
 Copywriting (6567)
 Crafts (18204)
 Cuisine (7538)
 Current Affairs (20383)
 Dating (45774)
 EBooks (19685)
 E-Commerce (48195)
 Education (185189)
 Electronics (83491)
 Email (6390)
 Entertainment (159825)
 Environment (28933)
 Ezine (3039)
 Ezine Publishing (5445)
 Ezine Sites (1554)
 Family & Parenting (110898)
 Fashion & Cosmetics (196384)
 Female Entrepreneurs (11842)
 Feng Shui (130)
 Finance & Investment (310266)
 Fitness (105941)
 Food & Beverages (62852)
 Free Web Resources (7938)
 Gambling (30219)
 Gardening (25086)
 Government (10513)
 Health (629311)
 Hinduism (2206)
 Hobbies (44032)
 Home Business (91544)
 Home Improvement (251325)
 Home Repair (46119)
 Humor (4817)
 Import - Export (5450)
 Insurance (45126)
 Interior Design (29545)
 International Property (3485)
 Internet (190974)
 Internet Marketing (146310)
 Investment (22824)
 Islam (1168)
 Judaism (1357)
 Law (80460)
 Link Popularity (4592)
 Manufacturing (20839)
 Marketing (98751)
 MLM (14136)
 Motivation (18211)
 Music (26999)
 New to the Internet (9476)
 Non-Profit Organizations (4048)
 Online Shopping (129613)
 Organizing (7802)
 Party Ideas (11856)
 Pets (38081)
 Poetry (2234)
 Press Release (12671)
 Public Speaking (5618)
 Publishing (7523)
 Quotes (2407)
 Real Estate (126613)
 Recreation & Leisure (95259)
 Relationships (87450)
 Research (16157)
 Sales (80313)
 Science & Technology (110166)
 Search Engines (23447)
 Self Improvement (153090)
 Seniors (6230)
 Sexuality (35942)
 Small Business (49280)
 Software (82972)
 Spiritual (23461)
 Sports (116076)
 Tax (7658)
 Telecommuting (34064)
 Travel & Tourism (307212)
 UK Property Investment (3118)
 Video Games (13423)
 Web Traffic (11724)
 Website Design (56804)
 Website Promotion (36557)
 World News (1000+)
 Writing (35762)
Author Spotlight

I am a graphic designer/Internet Marketer. ...more

Shovon Joarder has been working as Freelance Marketing Project Manager for over four years. He also ...more

I am an American author who loves to find out about new things. I try to cover as many topics as I c...more

I am in Nepalest tourism industery working since 2000 as a trekking porter to the senior tour leader...more

I have been involved in nutrition and weight management for over 12 years and I like to share my kn...more

The Ethics of Medical Law: Texas and the Munoz Family Tragedy by stephanie taylor

Article Author Biography
The Ethics of Medical Law: Texas and the Munoz Family Tragedy by
Article Posted: 02/15/2014
Article Views: 338
Articles Written: 2
Word Count: 837
Article Votes: 0
AddThis Social Bookmark Button

The Ethics of Medical Law: Texas and the Munoz Family Tragedy

Should the government be allowed control over your medical decisions? A lot of us most likely have the necessary paperwork to instruct our loved ones of our wishes upon a timely accident or a life ending circumstance. However, in the state of Texas, this is not always enough to suffice depending on the circumstances. Did John Peter Smith Hospital act appropriately when placing Marlise Munoz on life support? Was cultural relativism a deciding factor when medical professionals were weighing the rights of the patient? The state of Texas has taken away these rights from individuals in certain circumstances as a futility review process was enacted in 1999, allowing health care providers the right to make that final decision based on individual circumstances. Texas Advance Directives Act of 1999 (TADA) in part states that “a person may not withdraw or withhold life sustaining treatment under this subchapter from a pregnant person” (Texas, §166.046). No one wants to see or experience the suffering and prolonging of the inevitable in the one they love when the end is near. Unfortunately, that is exactly what happened to the Munoz family in Texas last November. Marlise Munoz, a daughter, wife and mother of a 15 month old son who was 14 weeks pregnant when she suffered from a pulmonary embolism and was placed on life support against her own wishes as well as those of her family. The attending physician at John Peter Smith Hospital declared Marlise officially brain dead but due to her unborn fetus placed her on life support against the wishes of her family, citing TADA. When the family petitioned state District Judge R.H. Wallace to force the hospital into removing the life support, the hospital refused to do so, once again citing TADA as their legal stance. Removing life support at this point would cause an unviable fetus to succumb to death. Texas is the sixth ranking most protected pro-life state. They are the 12th state to pass the strictest ever abortion law; banning abortions after 20 weeks and will “force the closure of all but a handful of the clinics that perform them” (O’Neil, 2013). With this very controversial issue, could there have been a political fallout in the community had the fetus not been supplied life support via Marlise? Could there be a heavy decline in state and community donations to the hospital that resides in a dominant pro-life state? On the day the fetus entered its 22nd week, records indicated the fetus was not viable; it was not developing correctly, evidence of "water on the brain and heart problems”, (Baker & Campbell, 2014). With this discovery on January 26th, John Peter Smith Hospital followed the order made by Judge R.H. Wallace and removed Marlise Munoz from the life support system. Lawyers for the Munoz family are concluding that the law was misapplied by the hospital. Thomas Mayo, medical ethicist and assistant law professor at Southern Methodist University assisted in revising the advance directive section of this particular Texas Health and Safety Code in 1999. Mayo stated that when the statute was being revised the prospect of a brain-dead person coming into play was not discussed. “The statute was meant for making treatment decisions for patients with terminal or irreversible conditions”, (Mayo, 2014). There are more than 30 states that have this type of pregnancy provisional but this is the first known case of a hospital insisting on life support over family objection. In conclusion, did the hospital perhaps act unethically first by placing Marlise Munoz on life support against the wishes of her family? Secondly, was John Peter Smith Hospital negligent and morally unethical by forcing the misapplication of TADA? Because the hospital exercised what appears to be cultural relativism; believing it was right because the law says it is, in turn caused additional and tremendous grief for the Munoz family. This family was at the mercy of a hospital that exerted an inappropriate law forcing them to suffer through months of agony for their wife and daughter.

References Baker, M.B. & Campbell, E. (2014). Texas law didn’t anticipate Munoz case, drafters say. Retrieved from Colb, S. (2014). Verdict – Legal Analysis and Commentary from Justia. Excluding pregnant women from the right to terminate life support. Retrieved from Collins, D. (2012). Business Ethics: How to design and manage ethical organizations. Hoboken, New Jersey: Wiley Deruy, E. (2013). Texas passes strict abortion law. Retrieved from Kaplan, K. (2014). Marlise Munoz: Can a fetus survive after mother becomes brain-dead? Retrieved from O’Neil, T. (2014). Prolife State Rankings Released: 6 Best, 5 Worst, 4 Most Improved States for Life. Retrieved from Painter, R.W. (2009). Developments in Texas Advance Directives. Publication of the Houston Bar Association. Retrieved from Rovner, J. (2013). State laws limiting abortion may face challenges on 20 week limit. Retrieved from Silverman, L. (2014). Life support battle over pregnant Texas woman heads to court. Retrieved from

Related Articles - Munoz, TADA, fetus,

Email this Article to a Friend!

Receive Articles like this one direct to your email box!
Subscribe for free today!

 Rate This Article  
Completely useless, should be removed from directory.
Minimal useful information.
Decent and informative.
Great article, very informative and helpful.
A 'Must Read'.


Do you Agree or Disagree? Have a Comment? POST IT!

 Reader Opinions 
Submit your comments and they will be posted here.
Make this comment or to the Author only:
*Your email will NOT be posted. This is for administrative purposes only.
Comments: *Your Comments WILL be posted to the AUTHOR ONLY if you select PRIVATE and to this PUBLIC PAGE if you select PUBLIC, so write accordingly.
Please enter the code in the image:

 Author Login 
Register for Author Account


Advertiser Login


   Limited Time $60 Offer!
   90  Days-1.5 Million Views  


Great Paranormal Romance

World News


Steve Bye is currently a fiction writer, who published his first novel, ‘Looking Forward Through The...more

An experienced, resourceful and highly motivated IT professional, with a proven record of success in...more

Author of four books and two screenplays; frequent magazine contributor. I have four other books "in...more

Kiranpreet (Kiran) Kaur, D.D.S., who received her Doctor of Dental Surgery degree from the prestigio...more

Stevert Mckenzie, Travel Enthusiast. ...more

Anita Waggoner grew up in a small town in Eastern Washington. She attended business-college in the S...more

At LeadGenerators, we specialise in content-led Online Marketing Strategies for our clients in the t...more

Susan Friesen, founder of the award-winning web development and digital marketing firm eVision Media...more

Michael Mifsud was a House of Commons Commonwealth correspondent at the age of 16. He published Brit...more

Warm greetings to you!! Hello there, my name is Treena (Smiley) Murphy I am a part time blogge...more

HomeLinksAbout UsContact UsTerms of UsePrivacy PolicyFAQResources
Copyright © 2019, All rights reserved.
Some pages may contain portions of text relating to certain topics obtained from under the GNU FDL license